130 N Commerce St
Lewisburg, OH 45338

Fax: 937-962-2678


Home and Auto Insurance in Lewisburg, OH

Jack Heeter started Heeter Insurance Agency with Motorist Mutual Insurance Company in January 1952. The agency has been passed down through many local hands, from Jack Heeter, to Bonnie and Jon Tucker, and finally to Jim Simon in 2006.


Hard work is part of the Heeter legacy, stemming back from the time Jack Heeter was meeting with clients in their homes to help them with their insurance protection needs, and as a result, our community ties run deep.

Personal Lines Insurance, Business Insurance, and Niche Commercial Insurance in Lewisburg, OH

Heeter Insurance Agency offers essential insurance products, including home insurance and auto insurance. Our agents are happy to provide excellent and attentive insurance advice to all clients, and will manage both personal and commercial accounts.


Our commercial offerings include medical malpractice insurance, construction insurance, auto repair shop insurance, professional liability insurance, cyber liability insurance and more.

Long Established Insurance Service with History in Lewisburg

We encourage clients to ask about our agency’s history in Lewisburg, OH. Our business has been a staple in the community for many years, and we are committed to preserving other businesses and families here.


When Jack Heeter started the agency in 1952, he was delivering coal and fuel oil for his father, Otto, through their office on Western Avenue.  Jack acquired Motorists Mutual book of business from Bob Blackburn, a teacher at Lewisburg Union School, who had been with Motorists Mutual since 1939.  Through the years, the agency has changed hands, but the original commitment to excellent service to Lewisburg residents has remained strong.


If you’re looking for an insurance agency that provides lasting quality service, speak to an agent or request a proposal today.


Additional Resources

Request A Quote


Meet Our Team

Jim Simon
Jim Simon


Lorrie Ullery
Lorrie Ullery

Account Manager

Teresa Thompson
Teresa Thompson

Account Manager

Todd Appledorn
Todd Appledorn

Account Executive



Accommodating, professional, helpful, and quick. Very comfortable experience and I was impressed by their capabilities. Highly recommended.

Brad M.

I feel lucky to have found an agent willing to provide this level of service. No need to look anywhere else!

Michelle D.

Over the years we've never once had to worry about our coverage. My husband and I are long-time customers and proud to be.

Carol S.

Surprisingly flexible and in-touch with my needs as a small business owner. Can't ask for more.

Spencer F.

They have strong ties with the community, and it shows. It's nice to do business with people that really show they care about you and your family.

Susan T.

Contact Us